Producer Jerry Bruckheimer thinks big, and his war movies can range from noisy idiocy (Pearl Harbor) to near brilliant (Black Hawk Down). Luckily, 12 Strong sees the value in substance as well as spectacle. Based on Doug Stanton's 2009 bestseller, Horse Soldiers: The Extraordinary Story of a Band of U.S. Soldiers Who Rod to Victory in Afghanistan, this rough-hewn drama has a compelling, mostly untold story to relate. After 9/11, an elite Special Forces unit comprised of 12 Green Berets led by Captain Mitch Nelson (Chris Hemsworth), were dropped into Afghanistan in response to the attack. Their mission impossible – codenamed: Task Force Dagger – was to link up with the Northern Alliance, headed by General Abdul Rashid Dostum (Navid Negahban), to take on the Taliban and its Al Qaeda followers. He's show the U.S. team where the enemy was located. Nelson's group would then join in the battle on land and order bomb strikes from the air.
Related 50 Most Anticipated Movies of 2018 From a solo Black Panther to a young Han Solo, Spielberg going retro to Barry Jenkins doing James Baldwin – the films we can't wait to see this year
What seemed simple on paper was, of course, a whole other another thing reality-wise. The captain and his men knew nothing of the Afghan terrain – one dotted T-72 tanks and missile launchers – or had the experience of riding horses, which was the only way to maneuver on this unfamiliar landscape of sand and mountains. Not only did the Americans have to practice diplomacy by cementing a bond with the Northern Alliance, they had to learn to fight Afghan-style to survive. And that saddling up.
It's a hell of a tale, and Danish director Nicolai Fuglsig, a former photojournalist and creator of award-winning TV commercials, had his work cut out for him. It had to look and feel real (the production shot in New Mexico), and the filmmaker certainly delivers. The action scenes pulsate with the hum of modern warfare. Credit Hemsworth for playing Nelson not as some Norse God out of Marvel fantasy (that's his day job) but as a man of courage forced to improvise on his feet or die trying. The rest of the cast also perform beyond the call of escapist duty. Michael Shannon is outstanding as the Chief Warrant Officer, a fighter who has seen combat, unlike his captain. Michael Pena and Trevante Rhodes – so good in the Oscar-winning Moonlight – also score as members of the team.
If you're thinking these characters are drawn in conventional lines by screenwriters Peter Craig and Oscar winner Ted Tally (Silence of the Lambs), you're not wrong. The script doesn't go much beyond the surface in establishing the camaraderie among these men who left their families to take on a battle still being fought. This is not a movie with time on its hands for character development or scrappy discussions of the politics involved on both sides. What 12 Strong does deliver, however, is a rousing tribute to the bravery of soldiers whose contributions went unheralded for years. That impact cannot be denied.
Photo: Warner Bros.
Movie Review Movie Review 12 Strong C+ Movie Review 12 Strong C+ C+ 12 Strong Director Nicolai Fuglsig Runtime 130 minutes Rating R Language English Cast Chris Hemsworth, Michael Shannon, Navid Negahban, Michael Peña, Trevante Rhodes, William Fichtner, Rob Riggle Availability Theaters everywhere January 19
It’s become Hollywood tradition to sound reveille at the start of the year with stories of heroic Navy SEALs, Green Berets, and CIA contractors aimed at putting red-state butts into seats, and close out with a quavering awards-season “Taps” of dutiful acknowledgements that war is, in fact, terrible. And so it goes with the dusty, Jerry Bruckheimer-produced 12 Strong (a title generic enough to be a sports drama), a squarely-in-the-former-category wartime adventure wannabe that turns a real Special Forces operation in Afghanistan into something that feels like warmed-over John Milius.
Adopting a wavering American accent, Chris Hemsworth stars as Mitch Nelson, a captain in the 5th Special Forces Group—the old stomping ground of John Rambo and Col. Kurtz—who leads his team into northern Afghanistan to assist an ethnic Uzbek warlord in the fight against the Taliban just a month after the 9/11 attacks. With only three weeks left before the coming winter freeze, Nelson and his men have their work cut out for them: make contact with the warlord, earn his trust, and help his ragtag militia recapture a village and breach the Tiangi Gap, a narrow ass-crack in the mountains that serves as a supply route from the Taliban stronghold of Mazar-i-Sharif.
Surprisingly stolid and barren for a Bruckheimer production, 12 Strong skates by on the virtues of an old-fashioned programmer: technical competence, an above-average cast, and well-written dialogue, the latter courtesy of screenwriters Ted Tally (The Silence Of The Lambs) and Peter Craig (Blood Father). The director, Nicolai Fuglsig, is a Danish former photojournalist who began his career covering radioactive pollution and the Kosovo War, which may explain the relative restraint. But perhaps it’s best to leave the flag-waving camo fantasies to the true believers. His action scenes are strictly perfunctory, kabooms of gunfire, tossed rubble, flipping trucks, and air strikes executed with the same sense of obligation that characterizes the movie’s Special Forces heroes.
Photo: Warner Bros.
Only three of the men under Nelson’s command leave an impression: Spencer (Michael Shannon), an experienced warrant officer who is relentlessly loyal to his untested, much younger captain; the fidgety but selfless Diller (Michael Peña); and the lollipop-sucking Milo (Moonlight’s Trevante Rhodes), who ends up taking a shine to a bothersome local kid, as American servicemen in movies about war in the Middle East are wont to do. Not that these characters are all that well-developed (though there is a small, effective vignette early in the film with Spencer and his family), but at least the viewer might end up remembering their names. That’s more than can be said for the rest of the group, who are a blur of gear, injuries, orders, and wisecracks.
Advertisement
One might argue that’s because it’s supposed to be about “the mission.” But what’s the mission about, anyway? For a war film, 12 Strong is short on conflict and adrenaline; it sings the praises of exceptional men, frontline camaraderie, and unlikely odds with all the passion of a grunt following orders. Like most exercises in January jingo, it’s a “true,” “declassified” story, adapted from Doug Stanton’s nonfiction book Horse Soldiers: The Extraordinary Story Of A Band Of US Soldiers Who Rode to Victory In Afghanistan—and like the rest of them, it’s about as real as a G.I. Joe action figure. American Sniper, the best of the lot, ignored Chris Kyle’s fabulism, forfeiting possible insight into the psychology of a self-made culture-wars hero. But at least it tried to depict the consequences of traumatic stress.
At the ill-defined center of 12 Strong is the relationship between Nelson and the film’s most Milius-ian character, Abdul Rashid Dostum (Navid Negahban), the aforementioned Uzbek warlord, portrayed as a figure of almost medieval nobility. As the expected end-titles epilogue helpfully announces, Dostum would later go on to become vice president of Afghanistan, though it fails to mention the fact that he is currently hiding out in Turkey to avoid prosecution for the kidnapping, rape, and torture of a political rival. Good people might find themselves fighting in wars, but they aren’t likely to lead them. 12 Strong, however, contents itself with peddling the same crap about pure valor and warrior ethos that’s been around since wars were actually fought on horseback—and it doesn’t even have the decency to reward viewers a rousing cavalry charge.
CLOSE The first trailer for '12 Strong,' starring Chris Hemsworth, the true story of Green Berets who ride into battle in Afghanistan after 9/11 on horses.
Mitch Nelson (Chris Hemsworth, center) leads his Green Berets on horseback against Taliban fighters in '12 Strong.' (Photo: David James)
Sans magic hammer, Chris Hemsworth's career as a leading man is spotty at best. It seems he just needed horse co-stars.
The Thor star saddles up as an Army Special Forces captain in 12 Strong (★★½ out of four; rated R; in theaters nationwide Friday), a commendable war drama based on the first American military offensive in Afghanistan following 9/11.
Director Nicolai Fuglsig’s action film, based on Doug Stanton's 2009 book Horse Soldiers, isn't particularly innovative in terms of genre storytelling — gruff, scenery-chewing officers and homefront drama? Check and check. However, the movie successfully digs into the diplomacy of the time and mines the fragile emotions in those early days in the war on terror. Also in its favor: a thrilling battle with good guys on equine transport vs. an army of tanks and missile launchers.
After a couple years training with his unit of Green Berets, Capt. Mitch Nelson (played by Hemsworth) has transferred to a cushy desk job when he and his family watch in horror as two planes strike the World Trade Center. Even though he's never actually seen combat, Mitch fights to get redeployed with Chief Warrant Officer Hal Spencer (Michael Shannon) and the rest of his men, who all volunteer to head to Afghanistan as part of Task Force Dagger. The mission teams their elite squad with Afghan warlord Gen. Dostum (Navid Negahban) to take back Taliban-controlled locales, battle an enemy force of 50,000 combatants and deal a hefty blow to al-Qaeda.
More: Chris Hemsworth goes into '12 Strong' battle pondering Thor's future
Related: '12 Strong' co-stars were in for a bumpy ride as horse soldiers
The rub? The Green Berets have to ride into conflict on horseback because of the mountains, and Mitch has to befriend Dostum and smooth over feelings when a parallel mission arises involving a rival general in the anti-Taliban Northern Alliance.
Unlike his non-superhero star turns in Blackhat and the Huntsman movies, Hemsworth’s charisma and physical presence really pop here; in the insane situation of soldiers on horses facing off with an armored division, he at least looks strong enough to survive the experience. The hilly terrain offers spectacular views and an intriguing battlefield for the cast.
Mitch Nelson (Chris Hemsworth, left) strategizes with Gen. Dostum (Navid Negahban) in the war drama '12 Strong.' (Photo: David James)
The distinct lack of character development in Ted Tally and Peter Craig’s adaptation doesn't help the various members of Mitch's Green Beret battalion: Most of them have more facial hair than personality. The exception is Moonlight standout Trevante Rhodes, whose sergeant develops a tight friendship with a young Afghan boy.
Also: 10 books to read before they become movies in 2018
Earlier: 10 must-see films of 2018, from the new 'Fantastic Beasts' to 'Mary Poppins'
What 12 Strong touches on in a real way, though fleetingly in order to get on with all that horse-on-tank action, is the commitment to service following the fateful day in 2001. Mitch and his troops don’t have to think hard about fighting back, yet they’re torn between duty and the families they’re choosing to leave behind. Mitch’s spouse (played by Hemsworth’s real-life wife, Elsa Pataky) takes it mostly in knowing stride, making him promise to return home, though Spencer’s offers a savage rebuke: “I will love you when you get back.”
There’s the necessary gripping emotion, for sure, and also the huge battleground set pieces a war drama demands, though 12 Strong goes a little too over the top with its action-packed climax — obviously, real horses couldn’t be used in the more harrowing danger, and the visual effects are iffy in certain moments. Hemsworth’s machismo is all real, though, and for two war-torn hours, you’ll forget about that iconic hammer of his.
Read or Share this story: https://usat.ly/2mCIumO
CLOSE The first trailer for '12 Strong,' starring Chris Hemsworth, the true story of Green Berets who ride into battle in Afghanistan after 9/11 on horses.
Geoff Stults, left, shows off a personal photo with Chris Hemsworth while shooting '12 Strong.' (Photo: Courtesy of Geoff Stults)
FORT CAMPBELL, Ky. — Within hours of the 9/11 attacks, 12 men from America’s most elite forces were gearing up to head into a place they knew nearly nothing about with the weight of a nation on their shoulders.
Thousands had died in New York, Washington, D.C. and Pennsylvania, and at this sprawling military post, one of the few immediate response teams tasked with taking down the Taliban regime was forming as millions of other Americans grieved over the loss of life.
More: Chris Hemsworth goes into '12 Strong' battle pondering Thor's future
More: Chris Hemsworth's '12 Strong' co-stars were in for a bumpy ride as horse soldiers
The story of that first response, and what a single 12-man team from Fort Campbell's 5th Special Forces Group did in northern Afghanistan on horseback will be among the season’s biggest Hollywood releases in “12 Strong,” which stars Chris Hemsworth, Michael Shannon, Michael Peña and Elsa Pataky.
The film by Jerry Bruckheimer, based on the book “Horse Soldiers” by Doug Stanton, was screened Sunday for a theater full of current and former members of that 12-man team and others in America’s most elite Army units based here.
The film debuts in theaters Friday.
Retired Lt. Gen. John Mulholland led a team of Green Berets and is among the main characters depicted in the film "12 Strong." (Photo: Courtesy 5th Special Forces Group)
Almost all of the troops ordered into Afghanistan in the immediate aftermath of 9/11 came from Fort Campbell, including helicopter pilots from the 160th Special Operations Aviation Regiment.
Operational Detachment Alpha 595 — one of several “A-Teams” sent to Afghanistan in the days following 9/11 — was given one two-part mission: Work with Afghan forces and destroy the Taliban regime, a strategy still being perfected on a larger scale today.
More: Watch the exclusive first trailer for Chris Hemsworth’s ’12 Strong’
“That was intimidating, yeah, and of course you realize you’re carrying the weight of the nation,” said retired Lt. Gen. John Mulholland, then a colonel who led the team into northern Afghanistan.
“Go do this, but you know, everyone dies here,” he said, referring to the fates of numerous armies dating back to Alexander the Great and Genghis Khan and later the British in the 1800s and the former Soviet Union in the 1980s who have failed in Afghanistan.
These 12 solders were outnumbered by the Taliban as they worked with Afghan rebels.
Mulholland, played by William Fichtner, is one of the few whose names weren’t changed for the film.
Andy Marchal was one of those men on that mission. He doesn’t consider it any different than the other classified missions he was a part of during his 20-year career.
“I didn’t see it as that big of a deal,” Marchal said. “I did what I got paid to do.”
But they didn’t have any of the gear and technology that most Special Forces soldiers have today.
Andy Marchay, a former member of a Special Forces team depicted in the Jerry Bruckheimer film "12 Strong," attended a special screening Sunday, Jan. 14 at Fort Campbell. (Photo: Courtesy 5th Special Forces Group)
“We went into that fight with a shameful level of resourcing,” Mulholland said.
In the end, the soldiers overcame steep odds to secure the city of Mazar-i-Sharif, a landing strip and a critical northern supply route.
Mulholland, who has seen the film a half-dozen times already, said some liberties were taken with the Hollywood production, which was expected. But he said the core of the story is true.
“I’m alive and anything they’re gonna show is gonna get you killed,” Marchal said, jokingly.
Mulholland said he hopes a much bigger message is delivered with the film, which is that when Americans band together and don’t worry about who gets credit, they can accomplish anything.
“There’s a lot of effort to divide us from one another, and it’s wrong, it’s evil and it’s detrimental to our country,” Mulholland said.
Reach Jake Lowary at jlowary@tennessean.com or on Twitter at @JakeLowary.
Read or Share this story: https://www.tennessean.com/story/news/2018/01/17/12-strong-hemsworth-bruckheimer-fort-campbell-5th-group/1036556001/
